This week I shifted gears and asked ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini AI assistants to write a blog post about our feline household in the style of the late great columnist and political commentator, Molly Ivins.
It was different from my earlier explorations that used the AI assistants to help process large numbers of documents, either using them as intelligent search agents, or to suggest ways of organizing both the documents and the multiple issues raised.
For the cat blog post experiment, I provided each with similar instructions.
write a blog post about the problem of living with four indoor cats that don’t all get along with each other, in the style of molly ivins. The four cats are Kali, the calico and the oldest at about 8 years; Kinikini, the big orange tabby who thinks he’s the top cat; Ms. Bessie, another calico who is a bit timid and gets picked on but is totally loving with people; and Kiko, a spotted black and white cat just over a year old who provides the comic relief for the family. Kiko, which means “spot” or “spotted” in Hawaiian, is a female. Kiko has not been afraid, and she has built a strong relationship with each of the other cats. A friend to all. A couple of additional things. Our house has wood floors and no carpet. We live in Hawaii, so have lots of windows and glass doors that bring the outdoors in, and that provide many vantage points for bird watching and sun bathing. And the windows and a double sliding glass door provide a view out into our large back yard that all the cats enjoy. Two large mango trees planted about 80 years ago cast their shade in the afternoons, surrounded by tropical plants and a large lawn. The cats can vicariously enjoy the outdoors and the bird life!
Each produced a draft between 700 and 800 words. They apparently drew on common descriptions of cats, their likes and dislikes, and their behavior. They were both able to turn the brief instructions into themes that carried through their drafts.
And both were fun to read. But it’s more than a little humbling. These computer dig into its vast training libraries and, in seconds, comes up with good workable text in the appropriate tone of Molly Ivin’s voice. Impressive.
Here are the lead paragraphs of each to give you the flavor.
ChatGPT: Living with Four Cats Who Don’t Like Each Other (Much)
In the style of Molly Ivins, God rest her wise-cracking soul.
Now look, I love cats. Always have. Something about a creature that can sleep 18 hours a day, demand food like royalty, and still act like you’re the guest in their house—it’s humbling. But living with four indoor cats who mostly don’t get along is like trying to referee a family reunion where half the cousins are feuding and the other half brought tequila.
Gemini: The Uncivil War Right Here in the Living Room
Your correspondent here has seen his share of political donnybrooks, but the current situation right here on the wood floors is starting to look like a four-way primary with no clear winner and a whole lot of caterwauling. Forget the Legislature, folks. If you want to see a real turf war, complete with entrenched incumbents, blowhard challengers, and a long-suffering populace, just try living with four cats who’ve decided peaceful coexistence is for the dogs.
I have to give Gemini higher marks for finding the Molly Ivins tone and maintaining it through the text, not simply using political metaphors but slipping in references to her Texas background as well.
Gemini’s description of Bessie is a good example: “She’s another calico, sweet as a pecan pie, but timid as a freshman legislator on their first day. Ms. Bessie is the long-suffering public in this equation. Both Kali and Kinikini, in a rare display of bipartisan agreement, tend to pick on her.
Clever, and a mighty fine imitation of Ms. Molly’s style of writing.
ChapGPT tried, but didn’t really get into channeling the inner Ivins, although it displayed a familiarity with the behavior of cats.
ChatGPT also added a description of Kiko grooming Kali that I consider that a hallucination. I don’t think that’s ever happened, and I doubt that it ever will. But most of the other descriptions of cat behavior are general enough that they fit this and a lot of other situations.
While both drafts are clever and fun to read, I’m struggling to describe my reaction. They are somehow too clever, too glib, but in some sense hollow, a good imitation of someone telling a story but with something lacking.
Maybe someone out there can help me out with this. What’s missing? Is there some telltale quality that the trained eye can use to identify that it was written by a computer assistant?
If you want to go further, here are links to the full text of both versions.
Cats by Gemini
Cats by ChatGPT