On to Walla Walla

Later this week, we’ll be arriving in Walla Walla, a city in the eastern part of the state of Washington, where we both graduated from Whitman College a lifetime ago.

The city is quite different today than it was back then, at least in one respect.

At that time, the crops grown on the surrounding rich agricultural lands were dominated by wheat and peas.

Today it is a land known for its wine grapes and wine producers. The area brags of hosting more than 100 wineries.

I don’t know if that would have made a difference to us back in our day as students, although I imagine it might have shifted some of my early alcohol consumption from beer to wine.

In any case, I’m preparing with a bit of reading: “Unsettled Ground: The Whitman Massacre and Its Shifting Legacy in the American West,” by Cassandra Tate. Downloaded as an ebook from Amazon prior to our departure.

The author dissects the changing historical narrative surrounding Marcus and Narcissa Whitman, who established and early mission, and became historical figures by being killed an attack by local indians.

History changes as it is constantly reshaped by ensuing events and beliefs. What was then commonly referred to as “the Whitman massacre” is now reinterpreted as the “tragedy at Waiilatpu.”

Early in her book, Tate reminds us that “history” in constantly being recreated and rewritten.

“…memory and story and history and fact have a fluid relationship. Heroes rise and fall to the rhythms of what scholars call “the politics of memory.” New facts are revealed, old ones dissected, and stories reshaped (and sometimes forgotten altogether) as political and social conditions change.”

This seems important to keep in mind as we try to assess the past, and the future, of Lahaina and, by extension, the rest of our island state.


Discover more from i L i n d

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 thoughts on “On to Walla Walla

  1. Ann R

    https://www.tiktok.com/@fortnisquallymuseum/video/6973379238552521989. Ian thought you might like this tik tok link. Regarding those “Americans” Marcus and Narcissa. Remember reading about them decades ago it was like reading about the lives of the saints. However, having NW Native American & Hudson Bay British ancestors in the NW I tend to look upon these American settlers with a more jaundice eye. The Brits were very canny, few brought wives to North America and intermarried with the local women, whereas the Americans looked down their noses at such unions. This was one of the reasons they were successful and expanded in Canada & the US. I remember reading of the pioneer Ezra Meeker (a Hop grower millionaire & author) writing about about the HB co employees & their Native wives saying they were stupid (my ancestor Thomas Dean also grew hops – not so stupid). You get a different perspective of history when you do your genealogy. Ezra Meeker had an overly inflated opinion of himself and was an ignorant old fart.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.