Category Archives: War & Peace

Trump blythly advocates a war crime

8 Replies

I asked Chatgpt this question: “Would the forcible expulsion of Palestinians from Gaza as proposed by President Trump be a war crime?”

It answered quickly.

“Yes, President Donald Trump’s recent proposal to forcibly relocate Palestinians from the Gaza Strip to neighboring countries could be considered a war crime under international law. Such actions may violate prohibitions against forced displacement and collective punishment as outlined in the Fourth Geneva Convention and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Legal experts and human rights organizations have condemned the proposal, labeling it as a form of ethnic cleansing.”

Specifically:

1. Forced Transfer or Deportation – Under the Fourth Geneva convention (Article 49) and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (Article 7 and 8), the forcible transfer or deportation of a civilian population from their homes during an armed conflict is prohibited and considered a war crime or crime against humanity.

2. Ethnic Cleansing – The forced removal of a population based on national, ethnic, or religious identity is widely considered a violation of international humanitarian law and has been prosecuted as a crime against humanity in past conflicts.

3. Collective Punishment – The mass expulsion of civilians as a means of retaliation or deterrence could also be considered collective punishment, which is prohibited under the Fourth Geneva Convention (Article 33).

4. Occupation and International Law – If an occupying power were to forcibly remove civilians from their territory, it would be violating the principle of proportionality and distinction under the laws of war, which protect civilians from mass displacement unless required for their safety.

Legal scholars and human rights organizations would likely classify any such expulsion as a grave breach of international law, potentially leading to accountability under international criminal mechanisms.

A Christmas letter describes island life after 3 years of WWII

Leave a reply

This is a follow-up to my post on Sunday of a Christmas letter from December 1942 by UH Professor Carey D. Miller.

Two years later, in December 1944, Miller sent a similar letter updating friends on conditions in Hawaii after three years of war, most of that time spent under martial law.

This post first appeared here in 2008.

With so many jobs lost, dreams deferred, and savings evaporated by the financial meltdown, wars continuing on several fronts, and uncertainty so prevalent, it’s useful to look back for perspective.

In December 1944, University of Hawaii Professor Carey D. Miller sat down and wrote a Christmas letter to friends conveying thoughts for the Christmas season.

“That much hoped-for-end-of-the-war seems to be receeding, though the general situation is more favorable than last year,” she began.

The explained that after finding herself annoyed about several small things, “I tried to be a cheerful Job-ana and think of all the things I had to be thankful for.”

And this became the theme of her Christmas letter.

Among the things Miller expressed thanks for:

• “…a good job and sufficient health and energy to carry on.”

• “…a comfortable home of our own. The housing situation is so acute in Honolulu that we feel almost guilty to have a spare room, even though it is frequently used by newcomers and visitors.”

• “…space to raise most of our own fruits and vegetables which give us a better diet and means jut that much less food to be shipped in.”

• “…the (household) help that we have….A girl from one of the other Islands who is attending business school is with us for the second year. She prepares the evening meal and washes the dishes. Her repertoire is limited, but she really does very well.”

• “And we have a yard man!”

• “…it has not been necessary to restore the black out. We can now turn on any kind of lights anywhere, any time! (Except, of course, during an air raid alarm).”

• “…I am thankful for good musical programs whether from regular records or rebroadcasts of such programs as the N.B.C. symphony concerts.”

• “…the event which will evoke the greatest thankfulness will be the end of the war.”

A Christmas letter written in December 1944 by University of Hawaii Professor Carey D. Miller by Ian Lind on Scribd

Trying to understand the Gaza conflict

4 Replies

I have long said that there are many just causes, but there are no just wars.

That’s why it is so very hard to watch as the war between Israel and Hamas causes untold civilian casualties, and is poised to escalate much further.

I’m taking the liberty of sharing a recent statement by the Quaker-based American Friends Service Committee on the violence in Israel and Gaza. I was on the staff of AFSC in Hawaii for several years in the 1970s, and later served on regional and national AFSC committees until I began working as a reporter.

First, a little background. This Quaker organiation has a long history of working in the region, and in other parts of the world where war creates vast human suffering. In the 1930s, American Quakers worked hard on behalf of Jewish refugees, and provided relief services to the victims of war without regard for politics.

In 1948, “the organization was asked by the United Nations to respond to the needs of those displaced during the 1948 war. In those initial years AFSC set up the refugee camp system in Gaza and provided for the needs of displaced persons in the Haifa region.”

AFSC has maintained offices in Jerusalem, Ramallah, and Gaza, where it has worked “to realize a just and lasting peace between Palestinians and Israelis while addressing urgent humanitarian needs on the ground.”

They have staff trapped in Gaza today.

The AFSC statement

We are heartbroken by the escalating violence in Palestine and Israel. We send our sympathies and solidarity to all who have lost loved ones. We mourn with you and hold all experiencing violence – and everyone waiting to hear if their loved ones are safe – in the Light.

More than 900 Israelis and 700 Palestinians have been killed over three days. Bombing of Gaza continues, and Israeli troops are being moved into position for a potential ground invasion. More than a hundred Israelis have been taken hostage. The borders of Gaza have been hermetically sealed and Israel is blocking the entry of fuel, electricity, water, food, and goods into Gaza, exacerbating the humanitarian crisis.

If attacks on Gaza continue and the borders remain sealed, a deepening humanitarian crisis is inevitable and thousands more will be killed.

U.S. and European governments have expressed support for Israeli military action. The U.S. is sending Israel weapons for the attacks on Gaza.

The Israeli escalation is being justified by explicitly racist rhetoric. When announcing the siege on Gaza, the Israeli Defense Minister referred to Palestinians as “animals.”

Israeli military action is not what is needed now; it will only inflict more suffering. Instead, we need leadership that demands an immediate end to all violence and seeks long-term solutions to end the injustice and inequality that led to these devastating events.

Addressing this violence at its roots requires a clear look at the situation as it has unfolded over time. AFSC began doing relief work in Gaza in 1949, and even then we spoke about the need for justice for Palestinians. Our staff have been present in Gaza throughout all the Israeli attacks over the last decades, and AFSC has long advocated for an end of the Gaza blockade. We have witnessed the destruction, death, and suffering wrought by Israel’s Apartheid policies and ongoing use of military violence – all with U.S. support.

Through this experience it has become clear to us that security cannot be created by systematic oppression. Palestinians suffer from daily violence and collective punishment, while much of the world does nothing. One need not dig deeply into the history of the 75 years of occupation to find the evidence to prove that point. Look at the conditions this year:

The people in Gaza are in the sixteenth year of a crippling blockade, with little access to electricity, medical care, jobs, education, or other essentials of a decent life. Even before the Palestinian attacks and Israeli military response on October 7, during 2023 more than 250 Palestinians had been killed by the Israeli military. More than 1,100 had been forced from their homes. More than 800 attacks on Palestinians by Israeli settlers have resulted in injuries and property loss. All this persists under the watch of a far-right Israeli government who has functioned with total impunity.

This is apartheid. And it must end for lasting peace to flourish in the region.

We all deserve to live in peace, freedom, and safety. We call on the U.S. and other members of the international community to focus immediately on diplomacy to end this current crisis, to call for the honoring of UN resolutions and international humanitarian laws, to halt the flow of weapons which will further violence, and to change long-term policies that ignore the Apartheid realities and Israeli abuses of Palestinian rights. All of this is a central part of calling for peace.

As a Quaker organization, we believe peace is more than the mere absence of war. There is no true peace without justice and history shows us that people who are oppressed will continue to find ways to resist their oppression. The human costs of continuing along the current path are far too great. The only path to lasting peace for Palestine and Israel is by uprooting occupation and apartheid.

Resources:

“5 things you need to know about what’s happening in Israel and Gaza”

“How to talk with family and friends about the situation in Israel and Palestine”

“The Humanitarian Catastrophe in Gaza”

“The Hamas Attack Is Israel’s 9/11, Yet the Country Must Trace the Differences and Legal Pitfalls,” Lawfare Blog.

Thinking of my dad on his 107th birthday

3 Replies

My dad was born on December 7, 1913, in Berkeley, California. The family lived on Burnett Street in a home his father built. Several years later, they moved south to Long Beach, where William Grace Lind built another small house. My grandmother lived there until her death in 1982.

Meanwhile, my dad moved to Hawaii, arriving on May 1, 1939.

Here in Hawaii, December 7 is mostly remembered as the day Pearl Harbor was attacked, drawing Hawaii and the U.S. into WWII. It was a Sunday morning, and my parents had been out the night before at a University of Hawaii football game, and parties that followed. They were awakened by a call from my mom’s parents, who lived in Waipahu quite near to Pearl Harbor. My grandmother was initially exclaiming about the ultra realistic maneuvers, but when my grandfather ventured out and had his car strafed, they knew this was the real thing.

This year I’ll share a holiday letter sent out a year later, in December 1942. It was written by UH Professor Carey D. Miller, who had become my mother’s mentor at the university and remained a lifelong friend. In the letter, Miller describes the shock of December 7, and the changes in everyday life over the year that followed. It makes for very interesting reading.

Here’s an excerpt:

To read the whole letter, just click here (link updated/corrected).