Did you catch Gov. Abercrombie on PBS Hawaii’s “Insights” last night? It will eventually make it back to the station’s “video on demand.”
The program format was simple. The governor appeared alone with moderator Dan Boylan. The opportunity was missed to have a knowledgeable panel of reporters on hand to question him. Did PBS fail to suggest it, or did the governor’s office demur?
I have to admit that I didn’t make it through the full program. I changed the channel after Neil’s answer regarding disclosure of the names of judicial nominees forwarded by the Judicial Selection Commission.
Neil pitched it as simply “a philosophical difference,” a disagreement over the advisability of making those names public.
There was no one there to challenge this viewpoint, so the governor was successful in glossing over the issue.
Neil’s answer was that anyone who really thinks this philosophical difference is that important will have the choice not to vote for his reelection in 2014.
But the governor has framed the issue incorrectly.
There is a philosophical difference, but it’s about whether or not the highest elected official in state government should follow the law even when he personally disagrees with it.
That’s what we’re really talking about here.
There is a law regarding access to government information, and a procedure for determining what things should be disclosed and what should remain public. It’s a law that a lot of public-interest oriented people have worked hard to get and to strengthen for over 25 years. Under the law, the Office of Information Practices is given the statutory authority to make these determinations for state agencies, including the governor’s office, about what records must be publicly disclosed.
The OIP’s opinion is that the governor has the authority to keep the list of nominees confidential only until an appointment is made.
I don’t have any problem with Neil having a philosophical difference over the advisability of disclosure. I do have a serious problem with the governor refusing to comply with the law and the direction of OIP.
Too bad the format chosen by PBS Hawaii gave all the advantage to the governor, who could just blow past critical issues.


