Debating the debates

The credit for getting Senator Dan Inouye on the record criticizing the recent Hannemann campaign mailer goes to KITV’s Denby Fawcett. In a story broadcast on Friday, she put the issue to the Senator.

Inouye said, “Sure you can be proud of your spouses but to say my wife is Japanese and yours is something else, that is not nice.”

Inouye said he has always tried to keep his own campaigns positive.

He said making haole (caucasian) and non-haole comparisons ,and contrasting yourself as Hawaii-born versus being from the mainland can be a dangerous way to go in a political campaign.

“If you do that, you will have to keep in mind that some people might resent that,” said Inouye.

Interestingly, Fawcett reports the Hannemann campaign declined to comment on the story. During last night’s debate, Hannemann offered a contorted pseudo-apology that didn’t actually apologize.

According to KITV’s Keoki Kerr:

In the hour-long debate on KHON-2 Friday night, Hannemann acknowledged some people feel the brochure was “not a good way or a positive way” to point out the differences between himself and Abercrombie.

“If we caused that kind of uneasiness and suffering from some people who saw it that way, certainly, it’s regrettable, and I’m sorry if it caused you that kind of feeling,” Hannemann said. “On the other hand, there were people who were saying that’s exactly what we need to see more of. We need to see the differences between the two of you.”

I’m beginning to agree with Abercrombie that Hannemann has a way of blaming everyone else when things don’t go right. In this case, it wasn’t that the campaign flyer was offensive. It was the fault of those overly sensitive readers who had “that kind of feeling.”

Given some of what’s being said on the campaign trail, perhaps Mufi should have a chance to debate Kirk Caldwell over whether the mayor or managing director should have bragging rights for “management experience”. The charter does provide for the managing director and a deputy managing director to handle the day-to-day management functions of the city while the mayor functions as the policy-driving CEO.

If you’re interested, here’s what the City Charter has to say about the different powers and duties of the mayor, and those of the managing director.

So on paper at least, both appear to rightly claim to have exercised management authority while at the city.

I also have to comment on Peter Carlisle’s attempt to spin all those other city issues from his prosecutor’s perspective. He demonstrated the limits to that perspective in addressing a question about homelessness during KHON’s earlier mayoral debate. Carlisle’s answer, which suggested better use of criminal and civil laws to herd the homeless out of our way, seemed devoid of any appreciation for homelessness as a social issue and not simply a legal one. We obviously haven’t figured out the answer to homelessness, but that was one answer I found very troubling.


Discover more from i L i n d

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

27 thoughts on “Debating the debates

  1. Badvertiser

    “the mufioso” — LOL!!
    Interesting that the Moof claims to be more local, since he seems to think his rightful position is eventually in Washington .

    Reply
  2. fracas106

    One of the most amazing aspects of Muffy’s campaign is his attempts–as the certified representative of Hawai’i’s Old Guard–to paint Abercrombie with that brush. Nothing like a great “offense” to eliminate the need for a spirited defense of conventional wisdom.

    Reply
  3. 8toomuch111

    Why the hell does it always rile me when I see the race issue rearing its ugly mug or the purity of ones local roots ( as oppossed to the evil mainland born) exploited & held in such high esteem? Hey, don’t insult me & think I’m as narrowminded, superficial & idiotic as your campaign suggests…C’MON! Can we get to the real issues? huh? Put on your big boy pants and say it and mean it!

    Reply
  4. bob

    A month away from d-day……historicaly the leader peaks. Factor B = caucasian candiddates in Hawaii otherwise called Haole’s over poll and under vote. Factor = C for caucasian voters turnout is significantly less in non-presidential election years. Factor = D voters who often move and react on election day will be unable to find polling places due to huge reduction. If the polling place is found it will be very busy. Factor = E one-third of voters are seniors and they like free lunches and goodies in general. So candidate with lots of money get them. Factor = F the dreaded factor F is “fowl” it could be weather, football, free-beer at Irish bars for maindland born, or fowl play aka “F’d”
    Ian if all ealse fails run election day story that Mufi will reinstate “kill haole day”!!!!! and another story health department will outlaw the sale of spam on the neighbor islands for “kanaka’s” due to significant health risks under the polynesian health reform act. Doctor Shintani will be named health director first Haneman administration appointment.

    Reply
  5. 8toomuch111

    All this talk leaves me delirious & aching for POWER. Gee, if I could enact “Kill haole day” as a State holiday… (will my fair skinned Virginia born husband be displeased or perhaps delighted with a well deserved day of rest). Ya think?

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Badvertiser Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.