I’ve been thinking again about bloggers, journalists, and the intersection of the two.
This week, I sent the following suggestions to the Hawaii SPJ board concerning their annual Excellence in Journalism competition. There’s a lot of competition for their awards and they carry weight in the journalism community. They use independent judges who don’t play local favorites. What’s more, they aren’t afraid to refrain of naming a winner in a category if the judges feel the submissions are not good enough.
I’ve been an on-again, off-again member of SPJ, and last year I rejoined after several years out of the fold. One goal is to nudge the Hawaii chapter towards more appropriate recognition of blogs and other online journalism, especially those independent of the corporate media.
I have no idea whether or not they will be receptive, but if SPJ doesn’t pick up on the idea, then perhaps this is the time to create a new group to encourage recognition of excellence in independent online journalism.
To: SPJ Hawaii
Subject: Internet categories for Excellence in Journalism contest
I don’t think there’s any disagreement over the increasing importance of the Internet in delivering news, analysis, and opinion.
And there are a lot of journalists, myself included, who have turned to the Internet as a venue for writing because of the turmoil in the news industry and the relative lack of jobs in journalism. The Internet is more than the web sites of established news organizations. It includes independent bloggers and independent news sites as well.
In my view, SPJ’s Excellence in Journalism competition should include categories consistent with the breadth of online content produced by independent blogs as well as by the web sites of mainstream media.
Currently, your Internet categories are limited to:
I1. Online Spot News Reporting.
I2. Online General News Reporting.
I3. Best Online Multimedia Presentation.
I4. Best Web Page Design
I would suggest that these should be expanded to also include many of the same categories as in Print:
Government reporting
Feature reporting
Investigative reporting
Public Service Reporting
Column Writing/News
Column Writing/Features
Editorial OpinionIn addition, just as there are different categories for daily newspapers, non-daily newspapers, and magazines, as well as “Open Print”, it might be appropriate to further divide the Internet into entries from online sites affiliated with established media and independent sites or blogs.
Overall, expanding the categories to reflect the diversity of the online world would accomplish at least a couple of things. Organizationally, it would encourage bloggers and other online journalists to participate in the annual competition and, perhaps, join SPJ and serve as an entry point to other SPJ activities. And by recognizing quality online journalism, it would also provide an incentive for individual online journalists to raise the overall quality of online offerings.
Reactions and suggestions welcome.


![[text]](http://ilind.net/gallery_2010/cats080610/source/image/img_0669.jpg)