I received an email from a longtime reader with questions about the practice of elected officials using their campaign funds to make contributions to other candidates.
Here’s his email:
Hey Ian,
I visited the Hawaii Campaign Spending Commission website to see who is donating to candidates I am familiar with and was taken aback by the high level of candidates donating to other candidates!
Has this been a growing trend in Hawaii?
They’re easy to spot: “Friends of …” (fill-in blank with name of state lawmaker) contributes dollar amount to another state lawmaker. One candidate I researched received six different “Friends of” donations for a total of $8,600. That’s a lot of help from your legislative buddies.
For the candidate committee making the donation, obviously legislative loyalty is expected in return–or else, I guess. And if you are one of these “Friends of” candidates that receives free money in return for votes, your job just got a lot easier.
What say you Ian?
Are these “Friends of” committees wrongly exploiting campaign spending laws at the detriment of democracy or simply helping like-minded candidates get re-elected?
Michael Formerly of Waikiki
So I took a look at contributions to candidates made this year by the campaign committees of other candidates. I found 79 contributions with a total value of $92,100 made by campaign committees.
Below is a list of each of the contributions from a “Friends of (fill in the name)” committee.
I’ll be back later today with a follow-up looking at the law and my own assessment of whether or not this practice conflicts with the letter or spirit of the campaign spending law.
Contributions to candidates by
campaign committees of elected officials |
|
|
|
|
| Contributor |
Candidate |
Amount |
Date |
| Friends of Sean Quinlan |
Agsalda, Aaron |
$500 |
07/16/2020 |
| Friends of Tommy Waters |
Amemiya, Keith |
$1,000 |
07/10/2020 |
| Friends of Bandon Elefante |
Amemiya, Keith |
$1,000 |
07/16/2020 |
| Friends of Joey Manahan |
Amemiya, Keith |
$4,000 |
07/17/2020 |
| Friends of Glenn Wakai |
Branco, Patrick |
$250 |
02/28/2020 |
| Friends of Takashi Ohno |
Branco, Patrick |
$1,000 |
02/29/2020 |
| Friends of Scot Matayoshi |
Branco, Patrick |
$500 |
06/18/2020 |
| Friends of Clayton Hee |
Branco, Patrick |
$500 |
07/06/2020 |
| Friends of Chris Toshiro Todd |
Branco, Patrick |
$500 |
07/14/2020 |
| Friends of Kaialii Kahele |
Branco, Patrick |
$1,000 |
07/14/2020 |
| Friends of Aaron Johanson |
Brower, Tom |
$1,000 |
07/17/2020 |
| Friends of Della Au Belatti |
Brower, Tom |
$2,000 |
07/17/2020 |
| Friends of Mark Nakashima |
Brower, Tom |
$1,000 |
07/17/2020 |
| Friends of Sylvia Luke |
Brower, Tom |
$2,000 |
07/17/2020 |
| Friends of Scott Nishimoto |
Brower, Tom |
$2,000 |
07/20/2020 |
| Friends of Jarrett Keohokalole |
Chang, Stanley |
$500 |
05/29/2020 |
| Friends of Ikaika Anderson |
Chock, Coby |
$2,000 |
07/21/2020 |
| Friends of Glenn Wakai |
Clement, Jane |
$1,000 |
07/13/2020 |
| Keith-Agaran, Friends of Gil |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$1,000 |
06/29/2020 |
| Kidani, Friends of Michelle |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$500 |
06/29/2020 |
| Kim, Friends of Donna |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$500 |
06/29/2020 |
| Hashem, Friends of Mark |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$500 |
07/06/2020 |
| Ichiyama, Friends of Linda |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$500 |
07/06/2020 |
| Takayama, Friends of Gregg |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$1,000 |
07/06/2020 |
| Tokioka, Friends of James K. |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$1,000 |
07/06/2020 |
Yamashita, Good Friends of
Kyle T. |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$1,000 |
07/06/2020 |
| Baker, Friends of Rosalyn |
DeCoite, Lynn |
$1,000 |
07/13/2020 |
| Friends of Michelle Kidani |
Dela Cruz, Donovan |
$500 |
01/13/2020 |
| Friends of Ann H Kobayashi |
Dela Cruz, Donovan |
$1,000 |
04/14/2020 |
| Friends of Au Belatti |
Eli, Stacelynn |
$1,500 |
07/15/2020 |
| Friends of Linda Ichiyama |
Eli, Stacelynn |
$1,000 |
07/15/2020 |
| Friends of Mark Nakashima |
Eli, Stacelynn |
$1,000 |
07/17/2020 |
| Friends of Brandon Elefante |
Espero, William |
$500 |
05/12/2020 |
| Friends of Robert Bunda |
Espero, William |
$1,000 |
05/16/2020 |
| Friends of Ron Menor |
Espero, William |
$2,500 |
06/04/2020 |
| Friends of Ken Ito |
Espero, William |
$500 |
07/24/2020 |
| Friends of Takashi Ohno |
Gates, Cedric |
$500 |
03/04/2020 |
| Friends of Sylvia Luke |
Gates, Cedric |
$1,000 |
06/30/2020 |
| Friends of Ikaika Anderson |
Hanabusa, Colleen |
$4,000 |
02/18/2020 |
| Friends of Ann H. Kobayashi |
Hanabusa, Colleen |
$2,000 |
03/13/2020 |
| Friends of Ann H. Kobayashi |
Hanabusa, Colleen |
$2,000 |
07/14/2020 |
| Friends of Della Au Belatti |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$500 |
03/07/2020 |
| Friends of Gil Keith-Agaran |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$200 |
03/07/2020 |
| Friends of Rosalyn Baker |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$500 |
03/07/2020 |
| Friends of Sean Quinlan |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$500 |
03/07/2020 |
| Friends of Yuki Lei |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$250 |
03/07/2020 |
| Friends of Gregg Takayama |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$1,000 |
03/16/2020 |
| Friends of Mark Hashem |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$1,000 |
03/16/2020 |
Good Friends of Kyle T
Yamashita |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$1,000 |
03/16/2020 |
| Friends of Linda Ichiyama |
Hashimoto, Troy |
$1,000 |
03/19/2020 |
| Friends of Takashi Ohno |
Holt, Daniel |
$500 |
02/26/2020 |
| Friends of Chris Toshiro Todd |
Kapela, Jeanne |
$2,000 |
06/23/2020 |
| Friends of Nadine |
Kapela, Jeanne |
$250 |
07/02/2020 |
| Friends of Sean Quinlan |
Kapela, Jeanne |
$1,000 |
07/06/2020 |
| FRIENDS OF KAIALI’I KAHELE |
Keith-Agaran, Gilbert |
$1,000 |
01/21/2020 |
| FRIENDS OF MICHELLE KIDANI |
Keith-Agaran, Gilbert |
$500 |
01/21/2020 |
| Friends of Ken Ito |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$500 |
03/05/2020 |
| Friends of Aaron Johanson |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$350 |
07/15/2020 |
| Friends of Della Au Belatti |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$1,500 |
07/15/2020 |
| Friends of Linda Ichiyama |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$1,000 |
07/15/2020 |
| Friends of Scot Matayoshi |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$2,000 |
07/18/2020 |
| Friends of Mark Nakashima |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$1,000 |
07/21/2020 |
| Friends of Scott Nishimoto |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$500 |
07/21/2020 |
| Friends of Ikaika Anderson |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$1,000 |
07/22/2020 |
| Friends of Troy Hashimoto |
Kitagawa, Lisa |
$250 |
07/24/2020 |
| Anderson, Friends of Ikaika |
Say, Calvin |
$2,000 |
07/23/2020 |
| Bunda, Friends of Robert |
Say, Calvin |
$4,000 |
07/23/2020 |
| Ito, Friends of Ken |
Say, Calvin |
$4,000 |
07/23/2020 |
| Manahan, Friends of Joey |
Say, Calvin |
$4,000 |
07/23/2020 |
| Waters, Friends of Tommy |
Say, Calvin |
$1,000 |
07/23/2020 |
| Friends of Ikaika Anderson |
Souza, Keoni |
$1,000 |
06/29/2020 |
| Friends of Tommy Waters |
Souza, Keoni |
$1,000 |
06/29/2020 |
| Friends of Kaialii Kahele |
Souza, Keoni |
$500 |
07/20/2020 |
| Friends of Tommy Waters |
Texeira, Alan |
$2,000 |
07/09/2020 |
| Friends of Brandon Elefante |
Texeira, Alan |
$1,000 |
07/20/2020 |
| Friends of Takashi Ohno |
Todd, Christopher |
$500 |
02/24/2020 |
| Friends of Kymberly Pine |
Tupola, Andria |
$4,000 |
02/26/2020 |
| Friends of Ann Kobayashi |
Watase, Dave |
$4,000 |
07/01/2020 |
| FRIENDS OF YUKI LEI |
Yamashita, Kyle |
$50 |
03/10/2020 |
|
|
|
|
Discover more from i L i n d
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
WOW!!
While constituents drown in debt, lose jobs and homes, our politicians spend on each other. Auwe!
It doesn’t violate the letter of the law but the spirit is debatable.
If you look at where the money goes, you can see a pattern that follows leadership or those who don’t support leadership.
Did they ask their donors if it was ok to spend the money on a non-campaign (not their own campaign) expense?
Friends of Clayton Hee? What’s with that?
Thanks,
Another new wrinkle comes to light.
It would be interesting to make a tree out of this to see how far any one committee’s donations go. For example, Michelle Kidani’s committee donated to Gil Keith-Agaran’s committee, and then he donated to Troy Hashimoto’s committee.
The stink!