The hints that sea level rise and resulting water intrusion could have cause structural damage leading to the collapse of a high-rise condominium in Surfside, Florida, must be causing some sleepless nights for residents and owners associations in Honolulu’s many aging condominiums.
Of course, the cause of the Florida building’s collapse will likely take years to establish, but the release of prior engineering reports, and anecdotal reports of frequent flooding in the building’s basement parking area, are pointing fingers at water intrusion that eventually led to cracks in concrete, giving the water access to the internal rebar. Over time–the building is 40 years old–the damage could have been, well, catastrophic.
Some initial news reports following the Surfside disaster pointed to the possible role played by “frequent flooding in the building’s lower parking garage, including the possibility of water seeping up underneath through the porous limestone rock on which the barrier island sits that includes Surfside and Miami Beach.”
All in theory, of course. But most of Honolulu rests on multiple layers of that same porous limestone, and many of Oahu’s condominiums have been fighting flooding for years, including those in Waikiki, and across the Ala Wai along Kapiolani, where the water table has been rising. And then there’s Kakaako, of course.
Some may remember back in 1989, when a new Duty Free building was under construction in Waikiki. They foundation required excavating to a depth of 30 feet in an area where the water table was, at that time, just six feet below the surface. The contractor had to continuously pump water from the excavation as part of a massive dewatering operation prior to pouring the concrete foundation. And as they pumped, Waikiki began sinking. Buildings throughout the area, and along Kapiolani, reported damage from settling triggered by the dewatering. It brought public attention to the water not far below the surface throughout much of Honolulu.
And as sea level rises, the layer of brackish or fresh water floats on top of it, a process which accounts for much of what until now has been considered just “nuisance flooding” in many buildings, often in underground parking areas.
I know of one Kapiolani condominium that required major repairs after water began flooding into its elevator shafts during high tides or heavy rains, and another where persistent groundwater intrusion played havoc with underground equipment rooms, including electrical centers, and was believed to have damaged sewer lines running under the building. I’m sure these buildings are not alone. The gossip network between building managers and managing agents is likely loaded with other examples.
There are a slew of Honolulu buildings that have reached or are near the 40-year mark. Could cracks in concrete, and the resulting spalling, cause structural issues over time as these building continue to age, and water levels continue to rise? These concerns will obviously have to inform future long-range maintenance and repair plans for aging buildings, including shorter timelines for routine repairs, and ongoing testing of structural integrity of older buildings.